Policies and Procedures Manual

View the Table of Contents in a Word Document: Canada_Select_Manual_TOC.doc

View the Policies and Procedures Manual in a Word Document: Canada_Select_Manual.doc

Canada Select NL Policy and Procedures Manual

Table of Contents

1. Overview of The Canada Select Program
    • Various Boards
          • Newfoundland and Labrador Accommodations Rating Council
          • Atlantic Canada Tourism Grading Authority Inc.
          • National Canada Select Board

2. By-Laws

3. Licensing Requirements

4. Rating Process

5. Scoring Process

6. Unratable Properties

7. Processes
     • Complaints
     • Appeals
     • Audits

8. Cost of Rating Service

9. Questions and Answers


 

1. Overview of the Canada Select Program

The Canada Select program is an industry driven, consumer sensitive rating program which provides the travelling public with a consistent standard of judging accommodations throughout the country. The program was developed in 1992 using consumer research to identify expectations and items of importance at various Star Levels and Categories. Canada Select is designed to assess the physical facilities and services that a property provides according to established criteria unique to each category. Presently accommodations are rated under the following Categories:

• Hotel/Motel
• Bed & Breakfast
• Cottages
• Resorts
• Inns

Various Boards

Newfoundland and Labrador Accommodations Rating Council (NLARC)
The NLARC is responsible for administering the Canada Select program within Newfoundland and Labrador. The Council is administered by a Board of Directors consisting of 2 representatives from each of the following sectors: Bed & Breakfast/Country Inn, Hotel/Motel, and Cottage. These representatives are appointed by their various sectors at their Annual Meetings. As well, one representative sits on the Board from the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency, Hospitality Newfoundland and Labrador, the Department of Tourism, Culture and Recreation and Travel Trade. The NLARC meets 4 times annually.

Atlantic Canada Tourism Grading Authority Inc. (ACTGAI)
This Board is comprised of the Chair, Senior Rating Advisor and Provincial Government representatives from each of the Atlantic provinces. This board meets 4 times annually and is responsible for overseeing the rating program in Atlantic Canada. The ACTGAI is responsible for provincial audits throughout Atlantic Canada and is constantly investigating other sectors which may be interested in being involved in a rating system. Each year, the Senior Rating Advisor from each of the Atlantic Provinces travels to another jurisdiction and evaluates properties to ensure that the Canada Select program is being applied consistently with regards to criteria, amenities and quality.

National Canada Select Board
This board is responsible for administering the national Canada Select program ensuring consistent ratings throughout Canada. This Board is made up of industry representatives, Senior Rating Advisors and Provincial Government representatives from Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, New Brunswick, Ontario, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba and British Columbia. As well, the Technical Working Group which consists of Senior Rating Advisors from across the country meet annually for Professional Development Sessions and meetings.


2. By-Laws

Objectives

Rate all tourists related roofed accommodations within Newfoundland and Labrador to determine if they meet a minimum one star rating according to Canada Select criteria.

Assist sub-standard tourism establishments to improve and maintain a minimum one star level of quality.

Provide the public with a consistent, efficient and effective inspection/rating process which ensures only accommodations which meet the minimum one star Canada Select level are licensed by the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador.

Participation

Participation consists of individuals, partnerships, incorporated companies and/or associations, who are inspected and eligible for licensing of tourist establishments within the province, subject to the Tourist Establishment Regulations and Act.

Directors are entitled to one vote and may vote by proxy.

Board of Directors

Board of Directors shall consist of two appointees from all rated tourism sectors providing roofed accommodations such as: Hotel/Motel, Bed and Breakfast/Country Inns, Cottage and Fishing and Hunting.

Where appropriate, Directors are selected by their individual sector associations at their respective AGM’s from participants in good standing.

Where directorships are not filled by selection from sector associations, positions may be appointed by the outgoing Board of Directors of the NLARC.

The Executive Director or President of Hospitality Newfoundland and Labrador shall sit on the Board of Directors, as ex-officio non voting and, two additional directors will be appointed from the following groups by the Board of Directors; travel trade and consumer.

Term of office for Board members is two years and Directors may serve two consecutive terms.

A Chair and Treasurer are elected from the Board of Directors.

Provincial and Federal representatives are invited to sit as ex-officio non voting members.

Any Director who misses two consecutive meetings may be replaced by the Board.

A minimum of four Board meetings will be held annually.

Notice of Board meetings will be sent to each Director at least ten (10) days prior to the meeting.

Notice sent by fax will be deemed as received.

Quorum shall be 50% plus 1.

The Directors shall manage the business and affairs of the Corporation. The powers of the Directors may be exercised at a meeting at which a quorum is present or by resolution in writing signed by all the Directors entitled to vote on that resolution at a meeting of the Directors.



Annual General Meeting

The fiscal year terminates November 30th.

The Annual General Meeting is to be held within ninety (90) days of year end. Time and place to be approved by the Board.

Written notice will be sent to program participants thirty (30) days prior to the Annual General Meeting.

Appointment of an auditor is approved at the Annual Meeting.

Council shall present an Annual Report at the meeting consisting of a Chairperson’s report and Treasurer’s report, including a proposed budget and audited financial statement.

The first quarterly meeting shall include a Treasurer’s report containing an audited statement and budget for the next fiscal year.

Objects and by-laws may be amended provided a copy of the proposed amendment has been sent to the registered office of the NLARC sixty (60) days prior to the meeting. Such amendments must be sent to the participants thirty (30) days prior to the meeting.

By-laws may be amended by a majority vote of those present.

Quorum consists of 50% plus 1 of those present, including Board members. Chair votes only in the event of a tie.

 

3. Licensing Requirements

There are certain requirements which must be fulfilled prior to an establishment receiving their Tourist Establishment License. All accommodations must provide approval from their local Town Council as well as the Fire Department. In addition, a satisfactory inspection report must be received from the NLARC. The final step is to fill out a licensing application and have it signed and sealed by a Notary Public. If there is no town council in your community, then a fire approval is all that must be submitted. These approvals should be sent to the Licensing Division, Department of Tourism, Culture and Recreation, P.O. Box 8700, St. John’s, NF A1B 4J6. It is recommended that potential new operators contact their nearest Government Service Centre (GSC) to ensure that all requirements have been met. The following is a list of GSC’s located throughout the province:

St. John’s 729-3699
Clarenville 466-4060
Grand Falls-Windsor 292-4206
Happy Valley-Goose Bay 896-2661
Bay Roberts 786-5033
Gander 246-1420
Corner Brook 637-2204

A fire inspection may be arranged by contacting Mr. William Pippy of the Fire Commissioner’s Office by phoning 729-3144.

It is important to note that the NLARC will not carry out an inspection if approvals have not been received and the property must be 100% completed. Upon completion of the inspection, the operator will receive an invoice for services performed. This amount must be paid in full before reports can be sent to the Department of Tourism, Culture and Recreation for licensing purposes.

 

4. Rating Process

The areas which are rated include guestrooms, bathrooms, public areas, kitchen/living room (if applicable), as well as restaurants/lounge and meeting rooms (if applicable). Areas which are rated include any public area to which the guest has access, as well as all recreational facilities located on the premises.

On average, 10% or a minimum of 4 guestrooms are inspected during an assessment. The guestrooms to be inspected are selected according to a proportional cross-section of the various types of rooms offered by the property.

It is important to note that, if more than 25% of a property’s accommodation units are sub- standard based on quality when compared to the other units offered by the property, the accommodation sector is scored on the basis of the sub-standard units only (i.e. the better units are not included in the assessment.

 


5. Scoring Process

Criteria and Amenities
In order to achieve a certain score, a property must meet and/or exceed all criteria and amenities requirements listed under that particular star level. Each category has its own Criteria and Amenities forms comprised of requirements specific to that category. For example, a 3 star Bed & Breakfast the offers private washrooms and room darkening window coverage, while an inn provides private washrooms at the basic one star level. In a three star hotel, guests can expect to find air conditioned rooms along with blackout window coverage. A three star cottage offers the guests an activity area with three items. Each Rating Advisor meets with the owner to determine the facilities and services the property provides on premises. Each line item on the criteria forms is then marked between 1 - 5 stars. No block is marked if the minimum 1 star requirement has not been met. Al items are verified during the rating process to ensure accuracy and any necessary corrections are made at that time. All line items on the criteria and amenities forms pertaining to guestrooms must be marked according to the minimum offered in the property’s guestrooms overall. After all the criteria and amenities line items have been marked, the lowest star level marked in each is transferred to the Establishment Rating Summary.

Example: A 20 room hotel has all the criteria items listed for 2 stars and all the amenities for 3 star. The maximum final star rating based on criteria and amenities would be 2 stars as the criteria rating is the lower of the 2 ratings.

Example: A Bed & Breakfast has all the criteria items for 4 star and amenities for 2 star. The maximum final star rating based on criteria and amenities would be 2 stars as the amenities rating is the lower of the 2 ratings.


Average Quality of Facilities
The average quality of facilities score is determined by assessing the bedroom, bathroom and public areas of a property and averaging the results. It is important to note that the criteria for this section are guidelines only. Each room or area is scored for quality based on where it best fits according to these guidelines.

A separate quality form is completed for each inspected guestroom. Each line item is scored by circling the applicable score in one of the blocks. The average quality for each bedroom is determined by adding the score for each item and dividing by the total number of line items. All average quality score sheets for the guestrooms are added together and the total is divided by the total number of guestrooms inspected. The same process is carried out for the bathrooms and public areas.

Determining The Final Star Rating
To determine the final star rating, the following must be taken into account. If the quality score is lower than the criteria and amenities score, the quality score determines the final star rating.

Example: If the Quality Score of a property was calculated at 2.26 (2 star) and the Criteria and Amenities score was 3 star, the final star rating would be 2 stars.

But, if the quality score is ½ star more than the criteria and amenities score, the final star rating would increase by ½ star. In such instances, the final star rating with a ½ star signifies that the property has excelled in the area of quality.

Example: If the quality score was calculated at 3.61 and the criteria and amenities score was 2 star, the final star rating would be 2.5 stars.

It is also important to note that it must be determined as to whether or not a property is rateable in the areas of cleanliness and state of repair prior to awarding a star rating.

 

6. Unrateable Properties

The star rating of a property must be calculated prior to completing the cleanliness and state of repair. Each area has its own evaluation form to calculate cleanliness and state of repair demerit points. Cleanliness and state of repair is done on each individual room. Accommodations units and public facilities are totaled separately. Deficiencies are noted in the applicable column by the appropriate line item. Each line item is awarded a weight value as well as a demerit value which are used to calculate the final cleanliness and state of repair demerit points.

Each property is allowed maximum number of penalty points which are determined by category, as well as the star grade which the property falls under. These numbers are found on the Maximum Allowable Penalty Points for Cleanliness and State of Repair forms which each Rating Advisor has in their possession (see attached).

If a property is within 5 points of exceeding the maximum allowable penalty points, a warning letter must be sent. If they exceed the maximum allowable penalty points, then a property is found to be unrateable. If such is the case, a star rating of 0 is awarded until such time as the deficiencies have been sufficiently corrected.

 

7. Processes

Complaints
All complaints must be forwarded to the Newfoundland and Labrador Accommodations Rating Council in writing. The first two complaints will be forwarded to the operator against which the allegations have been made. It is up to the operator to rectify the situation with the complainant. If three written complaints are received pertaining to the Canada Select criteria, the owner will be notified and an appointment for another rating will be arranged.

Appeal Process
Every establishment may appeal their rating. A written complaint must be forwarded to the office within 14 days of receiving the rating assessment. There is a fee charged for the appeal and it is equivalent to the original fee charged for the rating. The complaint is directed to the Program Co-ordinator, who in turn contacts the Chair. The Program Co-ordinator conducts the audit and if the appeal is successful, the fees which were paid are refunded.

Audit Process
A Senior Rating Advisor is selected by the Atlantic Canada Tourism Grading Authority in conjunction with the Technical Working Group. It is customary for two properties from each category in each province, with at least one property from each Rating Advisor to be audited. In recent years, any property which a Rating Advisor would like reviewed may be recommended for audit. The results are reviewed by the Chair of the Technical Working Group and compared to the initial ratings. A report is then forwarded to the Atlantic Canada Board.

 

8. Cost of Rating Service

The Newfoundland and Labrador Accommodations Rating Council is a non-profit organization whose sole source of income comes from the fees charged for a rating. The fees are as follows:

1 - 6 rooms $ 150.00 plus $5.00 per room plus HST
7 - 25 rooms $ 225.00 plus $5.00 per room plus HST
26 - 100 rooms $ 275.00 plus $5.00 per room plus HST
Over 100 rooms $ 325.00 plus $5.00 per room plus HST
“Off Year” Half regular rating fee
Upgrade fee Full rating fee
Reinspection fee 50% of regular rating fee

 

9. Questions and Answers

Q: Is a Bed and Breakfast rated under the same criteria as a Hotel?
A: No, to compare a Bed & Breakfast to a Hotel would be like comparing an apple to an
orange.

Q: If I pay my rating fee, do I automatically get into the Provincial Travel Guide?
A: No. In order to have your accommodation listed in the Provincial Travel Guide, your
listing must be received by the Department of Tourism, Culture and Recreation no
later than May 31st of that inspection year. You must also have all your licensing documentation submitted to the Licensing Division of the Department of Tourism, Culture and Recreation.

Q: Are properties rated annually?
A: Properties are rated biennially.





   © 2003 Canada Select    http://www.canadaselect.com